The weekend field guide
Record grading and pricing basics for record show visitors
Learn record grading and pricing basics before a record show: how sleeve and disc are graded, what pressing and condition mean for price, and how to compare copies.
Records are graded on two things, the disc and the sleeve, using a scale that runs from mint down to poor, and price follows condition, pressing and demand. If you learn the grading terms, ask whether a copy is an original pressing and compare a few copies before you buy, you will be a much more confident digger at any record show.
This guide explains the common grading terms, how to inspect a record, what makes one pressing worth more than another, how condition and rarity affect price, and how to compare copies without relying on one number. Dealers grade differently, so treat any grade as the dealer's opinion and ask how they apply it.
Why grading exists
Records are physical objects that wear. A record that has been played often, stored badly or handled roughly will sound and look different from one that has been cared for. Grading is a shorthand that lets buyers and sellers communicate about condition without hearing every copy.
There is no single official scale that every dealer follows, though the terms are widely understood. Grades are opinions, and dealers differ. That is why it is useful to ask how a dealer grades, and why you should examine records yourself where you can.
The common grades
The usual terms, from best to worst, are as follows. Dealers may use abbreviations on stickers.
- Mint: perfect, usually sealed or unplayed. Dealers use it sparingly.
- Near mint: nearly perfect, with no obvious flaws, and plays without noise beyond what is built into the pressing.
- Very good plus: shows light signs of handling or play but sounds clean for most listeners.
- Very good: noticeable surface marks or wear that may cause some noise, but still pleasant to play.
- Good: heavy wear, obvious noise, still playable.
- Fair or poor: damaged, skipping or worn out, usually bought for the cover or for parts.
Remember that dealers sometimes add plus or minus signs to refine a grade. A seller who grades with a strict standard may call a record very good plus that another would call near mint. Ask.
Grading the sleeve
The sleeve, or cover, is graded separately because collectors care about it. Look for ring wear, which is a faint circle where the record rubbed the cover. Look for seam splits along the edges, creases, writing, stickers, water stains, cut corners and missing inner sleeves or inserts. A cut corner or a hole punched in the cover marks a record that was once sold as surplus, and some collectors avoid those. Some titles come with posters, lyric sheets or special packaging, and a missing extra reduces value.
A record may have a beautiful disc in a worn sleeve or the reverse. Neither is wrong, and you can often buy a disc in a worn cover at a lower price if you care mostly about the music.
Inspecting the disc
Take the disc out if the dealer allows it and hold it under a light. Tilt it so the light moves across the grooves. Look for scratches that catch the light, scuffs, fingerprints and warps. Hairline marks are often only cosmetic, while deeper scratches that you can feel with a fingernail are more likely to cause noise. Check the edges for chips and the labels for writing or damage.
A record that looks bright can still be noisy, and one that looks marked can play clean. If a dealer has a player at the table, listen to a section. If not, ask how the record plays. Keep in mind that reissues and some pressings include quirks that are part of the sound, not flaws.
Pressings and why they matter
The same title can exist in many pressings. An original pressing is made in the first run, and a reissue is a later release. Collectors often prefer originals for historical reasons and sometimes for sound, and originals often cost more. But reissues can be excellent, especially careful ones, and may be cheaper and in better condition.
Ask the dealer how they identify a pressing. Details on the label, the sleeve and the run-out groove area, which is the blank space near the label, often provide clues. Knowing these details helps you compare copies. You do not need to be an expert on day one. Start with titles you love and learn their histories by asking and by looking at several copies.
Formats and sizes
You will meet several formats. Albums are usually twelve-inch records played at thirty-three revolutions per minute. Singles are often seven-inch records played at forty-five. Older records may be ten-inch or seventy-eight revolutions per minute and need a suitable stylus. Check what format you are buying and that you can play it.
How price works
Price reflects several things together: the condition of the disc and the sleeve, the pressing, the demand for the title and how many copies exist. A common title in good condition may cost little, while a rare pressing in near mint condition can cost a great deal. A famous title does not guarantee a high price if copies are plentiful.
Dealers set prices based on what they paid, their costs and what they think buyers will pay. Prices can vary from table to table and from one show to another. Comparing several copies at one show is a good way to learn. Recent sales of comparable copies, rather than asking prices, give a more reliable picture, though you should treat any single number with care.
Practical tips
Decide what a record is worth to you before you pick it up. Walk the room first, if you can, then return to the best copy. Be willing to pass on a record that seems overpriced. Another copy will turn up.
Care after you buy
Handle records by the edges, store them upright in inner sleeves and keep them away from heat and sunlight. Clean them with a soft brush or a suitable cleaning method before playing. Note your purchases, with date, dealer and price, to help you learn what you pay for what.
When you want to find more records, use the state pages to see upcoming shows, and read our guide to your first record show for tips on digging and etiquette.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between near mint and very good plus?
Near mint is nearly flawless, while very good plus shows light signs of handling. Dealers vary, so ask how the seller applies the terms.
Is an original pressing always better?
No. Originals are often preferred by collectors and may cost more, but a careful reissue can sound excellent and be in better condition.
How can I tell if a record is a reissue?
Ask the dealer, and look at the label, the sleeve and the run-out area. Details can vary, so compare several copies.
Should I buy a record I cannot play first?
If you can, ask the dealer to play a section. If not, ask how it is graded and whether returns are possible, and weigh the risk.
What does sealed mean?
A sealed record is still in its original wrap. Seals can be replaced, so ask the dealer what they know about it.
Where do I find shows to practice?
Browse the state pages in this directory and check each listing's source for the date, hours and admission.
Put your plan into motion
Find your next show.
Use the listing's official source to confirm the latest dates, public hours and entry rules.
Find shows in this directory



